choir practice you used to sing in saint mary's choir this was vocation-- opening your voice like a pocket watch-- like a tulip bulb-- it was march & i was fifth grade fat as a knotted tree trunk-- & the back seat of your blue jostled as we drove up past the air port dinner-- at night you would sit in the sun room tape recorder praying-- the choir director had recorded herself because you didn't read music-- mass happening upstairs as i sat in the dim living room-- i made communion of oreo cookies & apple cider & sometimes a metal bowl of grapes-- your foot tapping made the pulse of our house-- your guitar ached as it leaned on the book shelf-- i think i believed in god back then & maybe so did you-- back when billy & i sat in the gathering area after school while you went to choir practice-- we watched you through the glass windows into the church-- dusky golden glow of light behind the altar-- the rest of the church dull & shadow heavy-- monsters belly-crawling beneath pews-- sometimes we went outside & sat near the garden-- the one you had planted the year before with lambs ear & daffodils & the pinkish butterfly bush humming mouth full of bumble bees-- the grass turned indigo as we swallowed the sun like a eucharist host-- knees stained green we could hear every one of your ghost hymns as they emptied from stained glass windows-- i imagine the skull of god is something like those windows-- kaleidoscope & cavernous-- reverberating vaguely of your voice oh father forgive me-- i pinched the butterflies by the wings to hold them still-- took handfuls of mulch to feel the dirt beneath my finger nails-- but always paused when you sang the canticle of the turning it has always been my favorite song from church-- it's the only one i can sing now from memory